Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stuart Anderson's avatar

For once, I don't have much to say. I would like to point out that most of the comments here are directed to Liza, but this post is labeled as "a guest post by Emily Baldo" and the byline at the top mentions both of their names. So, thank you to both Liza AND Emily for this analysis.

Larkin is not my favorite poet, and this is not my favorite poem. His poetics are serviceable, so I'm neither wildly applauding not derisively hooting at the construction of the poem. It is really the content I dislike. Larkin's attitude ("philosophy" if you will) simply doesn't resonate with me nor convince me, and besides, the whole thing is a bit didactic. So in this case, I evaluate form separately from content.

I note also that most of the comments respond to the poem, not to the analysis. So let me be the first to say it: the analysis is better than the poem. You both do a very nice job of outlining Larkin's themes and noting his poetic elements, but this poem affords limited scope for demonstrating your chops, since it has little thematic depth or subtlety of expression. It is a "read it once" poem that doesn't really require much digging to get what is there. I am much more impressed with a painting that I can stare at for an hour than one whose complete artistic purpose I can take in at a glance, and the same goes for poems.

Nothing wanting in the analysis, just a poem in which I don't find much to sink my teeth into. YMMV, of course.

Expand full comment
Anonymous Dude's avatar

I had an even more pessimistic read: you can brood over death, but still the unpleasant work of living looms. You can look into the void, but there's still diaper changes and annoying phone calls to make. (A 2025 Larkin, if he were gay and hence allowed to be published, would perhaps use a beeping cellphone.)

"Meanwhile phones lurk, getting ready to buzz

At solitary bedsides, and all the vile scuzz

of our processed world begins to rouse.

The sky is white as clay, with no sun.

Work has to be done.

Laptop lights blink on from house to house."

Yeah, I know, there's a reason he's Philip Larkin and I'm not.

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts